New York

DSCF4911 In New York,  we decided to focus on cool new stuff we hadn’t seen.  And pastrami.  Our pastrami quest was thwarted as we trekked up to Carnegie Deli, only to discover that it was closed for repairs.  (And while we considered our next move, a dozen other people came along to be equally disappointed. Someone should set up a pastrami cart there.)  We did see Alwyn Court (even if we couldn’t afford to eat at Petrossian).

DSCF4820We only had two days to spend in New York, less than we did in Cincinnati. The focus on this trip has been on places where I haven’t been in a long time, places where we’re not likely to go to again soon, and places that you need a car to reach.  We had just been in New York last winter, and it’s likely we’ll be back soon, since we have a lot of family and friends there.  Then Greta and I came down with colds while staying with my brother in Mamaroneck, so our time in City got cut in half.  We decided to not spread ourselves too thin, and missed a lot of places and people we wanted to see (including an abortive attempt to schedule a Facebook-based meet-up with a lot of friends).  It was disappointing, but we’ll be back soon.

We wandered through the Park, and felt the full impact of the new residential tower at 57th and Park.  It’s kind of unbelievable, the tallest residential building in the western hemisphere, and a portent of things to come. DSCF4828

The Century used to be considered a tall building.  DSCF4833

On to some favorite blocks on the West Side.DSCF4843DSCF4845And over the the 79th St.Boat Basin, where the rotunda is looking a lot spiffier than it did when I kept a boat there in the 80s.DSCF4849

The redevelopment and park extension at Riverside South was interesting.  The new apartments were a tiny bit less banal than most of their era.DSCF4855cropped-dscf4860.jpg

But the real pleasure was in the park.  Back in the 80s, I was one of very few people who ever roamed into this territory – some homeless people managed to find gaps in the fence, and I would come from the river side in a row boat.  I was especially drawn to the remnants of the wharves that were there, as seen in these photos from the late 80s:Hudson-yards34Hudson-yards31I expected that some day this would all get swept away in a real estate development, so I was pleasantly surprised to see that the park design, by Balsley Studio, incorporated these pieces into a sophisticated design that covers the range from hard to soft and industrial to natural.  DSCF4865DSCF4876DSCF4894DSCF4888

And at the end of the park, there’s something else new to see:DSCF4907DSCF4915Bjarke Ingels’s new condo  building is his usual showstopper.  Once again, he lets the building form be driven by the site conditions, and doesn’t worry about conventional ways of making buildings.  I think this has worked really well in some of his projects, such as the 8-house, and less well in some others, such as the Mountain, where the concept may be strong but the execution is flawed.  It may be too early to tell with “Via 57West”, but I do wish they had hired a Danish branding consultant too and come up with a better name.  (Maybe they’re trying to attract Italian residents, and want to distinguish it from the buildings full of Russian oligarchs down the street.)  I haven’t seen the plans, but we spoke to a construction worker who said there were lots of weird, unusable spaces, which has certainly happened in some of his other projects, and seems like a natural result when you let the building volume drive the scheme.  I’ll withhold judgment.

But I think this may be a real New York building at heart, with the form driven by real estate economics.  One way to look at the massing is that it provides a graceful transition from the 57th St. canyon to the open space of the River:DSCF4932

Another interpretation arises when you find out that the whole block is being developed by the Durst organization.  The more conventional building further back on 57th St., seen to the right in this photo,DSCF4914now has a view of the River because the Ingels building slopes back.  So instead of one building with a view of the River and one with a view of 11th Avenue, you now have two buildings with river views.  The first one may be inefficient, not maximizing its potential floor plates and with funny unit designs,, but you can sell the units to hipsters who want to be in the cool building with great views, regardless of functionality.  Then you can have conventional units with normal floor plans in the second building, which will be bought by more pragmatic people.  The origin of this building is similar to that of Central Park – it may be a good design, but it would never have happened without the financial rationale.  I just wish it had a less cheesy name.

3 thoughts on “New York

  1. Jason

    I was fortunate to visit Bjarke Ingels’s studio in Copenhagen while at DIS and I’ve got to say that it was very exciting not only to see his very unique projects but to see a design process that seemed unlike any other I had experienced. I contemplated applying there and returning after my final year in Eugene just to experience that kind of firm/studio.


  2. Jerry Finrow

    The BIG project is kind of self absorbed in my view, you are right about the transition to the river, that is pretty nice but overall, kind of awful. I picked up on your comments about the riverside park, I think keeping some of the old industrial pieces was a good move, reminds me of the gas works park in our town, a nice gesture of respect for the past. Sorry you two got sick, that was no fun I am sure. Just to make you feel better, G. and I did to, seems winter is catching up with us.


  3. Peter Keyes

    It doesn’t seem to have a big urbanistic idea like the 8-house, but it is by far the flashiest building in the recent past in New York.



Leave a Reply to Jason Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s